How to Fix the NBA's Defensive Player of the Year Award

The NBA announced today that Tyson Chandler won its Defensive Player of the Year Award for the 2011-12 season, ending Dwight Howard’s three-year reign as the league’s top defender.  Howard finished third behind Chandler and Oklahoma City’s Serge Ibaka, who posted a highest blocks per game average this season that is the highest in more than a decade.

None of the Milwaukee Bucks received votes.  In the past two years, former Buck Andrew Bogut finished 7th and 5th in the voting, while Luc Mbah a Moute got a single third-place vote back in 2009-10.

No argument here on Chandler’s selection. Heck, Tyson may have been the best defender last year, too, when he anchored the defense on a championship Dallas Mavericks team. This year, he and Iman Shumpert turned the Knicks from a bucket-yielding sieve into a stalwart defensive team.

The problem, however, is that the award itself has become center-centric. 19 of the award’s last 21 recipients have been big men.  Below is a list of the 20 winners prior to Chandler.

Season Player Tm
2010-11 Dwight Howard (V) ORL
2009-10 Dwight Howard (V) ORL
2008-09 Dwight Howard (V) ORL
2007-08 Kevin Garnett (V) BOS
2006-07 Marcus Camby (V) DEN
2005-06 Ben Wallace (V) DET
2004-05 Ben Wallace (V) DET
2003-04 Metta World Peace (V) IND
2002-03 Ben Wallace (V) DET
2001-02 Ben Wallace (V) DET
2000-01 Dikembe Mutombo (V) TOT
1999-00 Alonzo Mourning (V) MIA
1998-99 Alonzo Mourning (V) MIA
1997-98 Dikembe Mutombo (V) ATL
1996-97 Dikembe Mutombo (V) ATL
1995-96 Gary Payton (V) SEA
1994-95 Dikembe Mutombo (V) DEN
1993-94 Hakeem Olajuwon (V) HOU
1992-93 Hakeem Olajuwon (V) HOU
1991-92 David Robinson (V) SAS

Mutombo is one of many big men to win the award in recent years (Photo: NBA.com)

Provided by Basketball-Reference.com: View Original Table
Generated 5/2/2012.

It wasn’t always this way — five of the first six awards went to wing players — and the NBA can clearly do better.  Sure, there will always be voters who look at steals and blocks while overlooking those who, you know, actually do the most to stop opposing teams from scoring.  (See above RE: Ibaka.  He blocked a ton of shots this year, but he wasn’t nearly the top defensive player.  His most notable improvement this year was to get better treatment from the refs so he didn’t have to leave with foul trouble.)

An easy improvement exists to improve, but not perfect, a flawed system.  Make a separate award for perimeter players:  the Sidney Moncrief Defensive Perimeter Player of the Year Award.  The NBA already names some of its awards after people, like the Red Auerbach Coach of the Year Award.  Since Sidney has not yet made his way into the Basketball Hall of Fame (which is not, it should be noted, an NBA Hall of Fame), the league can make this gesture to Moncrief, one of the league’s best defenders of the last 40 years.

Moncrief won the DPOY award in the first two years it was awarded (1982-83 and 1983-84).  He also remains the only guard to ever win the award twice. He is currently an assistant coach for Milwaukee.

And while the NBA is at it, they can dedicate the original award to interior players.  They should rename that one after Hakeem Olajuwon.

Why? Because it beats naming it after Kia.

Next Bucks Game Full schedule »
Wednesday, Oct 2929 Oct7:00at Charlotte HornetsBuy Tickets

Tags: Defensive Player Of The Year Milwaukee Bucks Sidney Moncrief Tyson Chandler

comments powered by Disqus