Skip to main content

Keeping Tyler Herro is already coming back to bite Bucks

It was always a risk, but no one could have predicted it would come this early.
ByFranco Luna
Milwaukee Bucks guard Tyler Herro (11) warms up before the game against the Cleveland Cavaliers at Fiserv Forum on Oct 31, 2026.
Milwaukee Bucks guard Tyler Herro (11) warms up before the game against the Cleveland Cavaliers at Fiserv Forum on Oct 31, 2026. | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Tyler Herro was supposed to be the veteran leader of a team lacking star talent. It made sense at the time on reputation alone: Herro is a proven, high-volume scorer who could either anchor the offense during a turbulent transition year or build up his trade value to be flipped for even more future draft capital. That should have been a win-win for a team that just lost Giannis Antetokounmpo.

But instead, he's become the roadblock to the development of Milwaukee's young Bucks. And perhaps it's time for Jon Horst and company to finally do something about it once the trade deadline comes around.

Tyler Herro hasn't been playing as advertised for the Milwaukee Bucks

Many questioned the decision to retain Herro once the offseason-season ended. It was practically a shared consensus that this was Ryan Rollins' team going forward. But nobody could have predicted that these performances would come so soon. Not many in the fandom believed that this drop-off would come this early.

To Herro's credit, his individual numbers look exactly like you would expect. He is logging north of 30 minutes a night, leading the team with 21.4 points per game and shooting a respectable 39.7 percent from beyond the arc. But the cost of that production is steep. Herro is dominating the ball, jacking up nearly 17 shots a contest and operating as the undisputed focal point of Taylor Jenkins' half-court offense.

So this is only to say that it's not all Herro's fault, and these losses have more to do with an overall lack of talent and cohesion on the team than any one player's shortcomings. But pieces like Brayden Burries and Kasparas Jakucionis are finally starting to come into their own, and Herro is still the one guard taking most of the backcourt minutes available on this roster. And if the Bucks want to finally lean into Burries and Jakucionis, then it's clear they have to address the one roadblock to giving them those minutes.

There's still merit in the Milwaukee Bucks keeping Tyler Herro for now

Of course, the main argument was always that having the star guard, who is one of the only pieces the team now has to established veterans, can also help their young talent by way of mentorship for young guards still finding their footing in the league. That still holds true even today. Fans don't know what's happening behind the scenes, and it's entirely possible that the two young Bucks are performing the way they are precisely because of Herro's mentorship in practice.

But the reality is that Milwaukee has been staring at a logjam in their backcourt for a few weeks now, and it's clearly affecting their roster construction as well as their play on the court. And with the difficult November schedule coming to a close soon, there's still little that indicates the front office has found clarity on what to do about that.

The time is coming soon for Jon Horst to make a decision about who stays and who goes. The Bucks have a chance to lean all the way into their new identity, clear the books of redundancies taking up opportunities meant for developmental pieces, and let the kids cook.

Add us as a preferred source on Google