Skip to main content

Tyler Herro's second-half benching opens new can of worms for Bucks

It'll be interesting to see what Taylor Jenkins does next.
ByDalton Sell
Milwaukee Bucks guard Tyler Herro (11) drives against Atlanta Hawks guard RayJ Dennis (10) in the first half at Fiserv Forum on November 15, 2026.
Milwaukee Bucks guard Tyler Herro (11) drives against Atlanta Hawks guard RayJ Dennis (10) in the first half at Fiserv Forum on November 15, 2026. | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Throughout the game of Musical Chairs the Milwaukee Bucks have been playing with their rotations, Tyler Herro has always felt safe... until now. In Milwaukee's loss to the Atlanta Hawks, they fought until the very end, and Herro wasn't featured heavily during the team's late rally. Now, it's unclear whether Taylor Jenkins goes for his boldest rotation change yet or keeps Herro as his starter and go-to.

Loss to Hawks poses question marks

Herro played under six minutes in the entire second half against Atlanta. Instead, Jenkins fully leaned on his bench guys, with Kasparas Jakucionis and Gary Trent Jr. getting an opportunity to shine. While not as impactful as those two, AJ Green even logged more minutes than Herro. Given Jakucionis and Trent's strong play, it wouldn't be surprising if Jenkins wanted to see more of them.

That, of course, could eat into Tyler Herro's minutes, especially if the Milwaukee Bucks also want to find room for Ryan Rollins when he returns from an illness.

Herro's subpar play lately would make it easy to justify him losing minutes. Following his blazing start, the guard has regressed mightily over his last nine games, averaging 18.4 points while shooting 37.8 percent from the field. The Milwaukee Bucks need more from their best player if they will continue to give him 30-plus minutes every night. If not, his minutes might not be safe for long.

Herro benching would be bold move

Jenkins is using a different starting lineup almost every night as he tries to find a band-aid solution to the team's many shortcomings. One thing he hasn't tried is bringing Herro off the bench yet, and it's unclear if he'd be willing to go that far. Given Herro's massive contract, it has always felt like a long shot to even consider, but after this benching, nothing can be ruled out.

Depending on who takes his place, it could make some sense. While the pairing between Herro and Brayden Burries has shown potential, neither is a pure ball-handling point guard. Perhaps Jakucionis' 25-point, five-assist night bodes well for his chances, as the Milwaukee Bucks could certainly use a pass-first floor general who can also score in the first unit to help set the tone.

With how turbulent the rotation changes have been, nothing is set in stone just yet. Herro could play 40 minutes in the next game while Jakucionis doesn't get a minute. Things are unpredictable. Yet, as the losses keep stacking up, pressure will rise, and Jenkins might start getting desperate. Anything could be on the table.

Stay tuned for more Milwaukee Bucks analysis.

Add us as a preferred source on Google