The Bucks had high hopes for their Giannis Antetokounmpo trade return pieces, especially Tyler Herro. Herro was meant to become a star this season in Milwaukee, and has been treated as such by the team. But he hasn’t quite lived up to the hype and looks very similar to his Heat self, even down to the scoring volume.
His most recent outing, a 5-point performance against the Hawks, was his worst of the year. But his scoring struggles aren’t limited to that game; they’ve been happening all season long.
Herro hasn’t shown an evolution into a superstar
This season, Herro is averaging 20.3 points per game. That’s a decent mark, but not even a career high; Herro averaged 23.9 two seasons ago during his lone All-Star campaign. The Bucks hoped he would at least match that level, if not far exceed it, with more opportunity in Milwaukee.
Despite now being the unquestioned primary option, Herro has only cracked 30 points once so far this season. And even that performance was a bit underwhelming as it came against the lowly Bulls in a loss. That Chicago team has some of the worst perimeter defense in the league.
While other Heat transplants have been able to expand their games in the freedom of the Bucks system, Herro has remained largely the same player. He’s still taking about half of his shots from three-point range and converting at a decent percentage. But Herro’s 2-point efficiency is down, limiting his overall scoring.
Herro isn’t even creating his own looks at a higher rate than his All-Star season in Miami. He might be putting up decent scoring numbers with solid efficiency (45% from the field and 38% from three), but it hasn’t been enough to convince a contender that he can be a missing piece. If the Bucks’ goal was to maximize his trade value, they’re not seeing the results they wanted so far this season.
Milwaukee’s options with Herro could be limited
Herro is in a tough spot financially with a potential free agency coming up. He’s making $33 million this season, but his contract will be up next summer. So far this season, Herro hasn’t done himself any favors when it comes to securing his next contract at a higher value.
His archetype - non-superstar undersized shooting guard - is quickly dying out or being devalued in today’s NBA. With Herro failing to stand out even with a huge green light on the Bucks, he could easily find himself setting for a lower value next summer, whether he re-signs in Milwaukee or somewhere else.
His impending free agency also makes him a harder trade candidate for the Bucks, since he’s not secured long-term. He’s probably making too much money this season, and demanding too many touches, to just be a trade asset as an expiring contract. But the Bucks won’t have a ton of suitors lining up to be the next ones paying him either.
